We are a small business so our cookies are only sold by the dozen.
Butter Frosted Cut-Out Cookies: light crisp classic buttery vanilla flavored cut-out cookie decorated with colored icing. Available in a variety of shapes. $30
Chocolate Frosted Cut-Out Cookies: light crisp classic chocolate flavored cut-out cookie decorated with colored icing. Available in a variety of shapes. $30
Brown Butter Banana White Chocolate with Walnuts: soft sweet brown sugar banana cookie studded with white chocolate chips and walnuts. $20
Chocolate Chip M&M: classic soft brown sugar and butter chocolate chip cookie rolled in M&M candies. $20
Fudge Mint Overload: dark chocolate fudge cookie filled with Andes mint candy pieces and chocolate chips. $20
Italian Almond Paste cookie: chewy Italian almond paste meringue cookie rolled in toasted almonds. $20
Mexican Wedding cookie (Pecan sandies): well known holiday cookie – buttery pecan shortbread balls rolled in powdered sugar. $20
Molasses Oatmeal Butterscotch: a marriage of two favorites: ginger molasses spiced cooke and oatmeal scotchie. $20
Monster: brightly colored M&M sugar cookies rolled in sprinkles with eyes. $20
Oatmeal Raisin Walnut: soft classic spiced oatmeal cookie studded with raisins and walnuts. $20
Peanut Butter: thick sweet dense peanut butter cookie with classic hatch marks sprinkled with sugar. $20
Red Velvet: sweet classic red velvet cookie with white chocolate chips. $20
Sea Salt Chocolate Chip: classic soft brown sugar and butter chocolate chip cookie sprinkled with sea salt. $20
Snickerdoodle: soft simple buttery cinnamon sugar cookie. $20
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut: soft, brown butter cookie with white chocolate chips and toasted macadamia nuts. $20
Any flavor you can think of, we can make!
If you are interested in ordering or if you have any questions for us, please contact Christie via phone or text at (920) 664-4666.
Or feel free to email Christie at muffintopsbakeshop@icloud.com; she will get back to you right away!